• Subscribe
  • Apple Podcasts
  • Spotify
  • Google Podcasts
December 13, 2021

Ep.1208: Do We Really Have Free Will?

Understanding the power of free will and why we have it

CHAPTERS

[00:13:17]
Does humanity's free will compare to God having free will?


[00:28:35]
Does God take away anyone's free will in order to accomplish His purposes?


[00:46:32]
What good is having free will if we all die in the end anyway?


Theme Scripture: Joshua 24:15

Outside of some deeply philosophical debates, the idea of human beings having inherent freedom of choice seems to be a generally acceptable premise. Free will makes us special. The capacity of conscious choice establishes humankind in a unique category in relation to the rest of life on our planet. When human beings interfere with the freedom of choice of other humans, the consequences are usually dark. We end up with things like oppression, slavery and dictatorships. Does God ever interfere with our freedom of choice? Does He ever override an individual’s chosen pathway and force them onto another one? Some scriptures seem to indicate this, but is it? How do we understand the value and application of human choice in God’s ultimate plan?

Continue Reading

Because the debates over free will are so varied, we will focus on free will as defined by three conditions:

  1.  The ability to do otherwise. This is the basis of free will, as it describes the fact that a choice exists because there are at least two alternatives.
  2. Control over one’s choices. We cannot be considered to be making a choice if we do not have personal say over the choices.
  3. Responsiveness to reasons. If my choice is based on “the luck of the draw,” I cannot be said to be choosing anything. Instead, I am simply accepting a result without any personal response to drive that acceptance.

When we look at the Bible, we can observe that God definitely gave humanity the gift of free will. This one thought can raise many questions regarding our relationship to God. For instance, if God gave us free will, then why doesn’t He give us better options to choose from? For the vast majority of humanity, the choices they are faced with always seem to be a mixed bag of good and bad no matter which way they go. If God loves us as we say He does, why isn’t there more quality in our daily choices?

Does God ever influence our choices so they really aren't ours anymore?

There are several scriptures that seem to indicate this is the case. If true, then is God contradicting the gift of free choice by taking it away from some?

Check out our recent podcast, “Do We Really Have Free Choice?” for more. We wade through the complexities of having a free will and discover the profound reasons that God gave such a gift to humanity. We look at several biblical examples that appear to show God overriding someone’s choices to find out what really happened. Finally, we put the whole equation together and discover how the whole freedom of choice thing fits into God’s plan. Free will is an extraordinary privilege. Join us as we uncover its power and place in the human experience!

 

 

 

 

Related Episodes

A hand reaching toward a glowing point of light with the words Doubting Thomas above it

Was ‘Doubting Thomas’ Really a Doubter?

/
Understanding the doubts and honoring the faith of the Apostle Thomas
Sunlight streaming through clouds onto the ocean with waves rolling toward a sandy dune

How Does God’s Providence Work in Our Lives?

/
Defining the process by which we can determine and follow God’s direction
A winding dirt path through green grass leading toward a bright golden light on the horizon, symbolizing the journey of following Jesus.

How Do I Know if I Am REALLY Following Jesus? (Part II)

/
Learning what the transformation of a true disciple looks like
A winding path through golden hills leading toward a bright radiant light on the horizon

How Do I Know if I Am REALLY Following Jesus? (Part I)

/
Laying out the fundamental requirements of true discipleship
An open book with glowing golden light shining upward from its pages against a blue background.

Does Our Preaching Really Save Those Who Hear?

/
Scripturally defining the primary purpose of preaching the gospel
A glowing golden cross radiating light above the Earth against a dark blue sky with small stars.

Did Jesus Die for Every Single Human Being?

/
Tracing the clarity of biblical teaching regarding salvation for all
Three older men with long beards wearing robes, standing together, with one holding a large stone tablet.

What Really Happened to Enoch, Moses and Elijah?

/
Scripturally establishing the truth about their end-of-life experiences
An old, worn book lying open. The left page has a handwritten note dated 1925, and the right page is titled “1 Enoch” with faded, hard‑to‑read printed text.

Why Is the Book of Enoch NOT in the Bible?

/
Examining the book of Enoch in relation to the canon of Scripture
A pink water lily with green‑tipped petals sits beside a stack of three smooth dark stones, all reflected on a glossy white surface.

Do We Get What We Deserve? Karma vs the Gospel

/
Uncovering the fundamental differences between karma and the Bible
Open wrought‑iron garden gate between brick pillars leading to a gravel path bordered by colorful flowers, including daisies, orange blooms, and tall purple and white plants under a bright blue sky.

Does Christian Liberty Give Us Freedom of Choice? (Part II)

/
Calling out the differences between true and false Christian liberty
An open wrought‑iron garden gate between brick pillars leading to a gravel path surrounded by flowers and greenery under a bright sky.

Does Christian Liberty Give Us Freedom of Choice? (Part I)

/
Defining what freedom in Christ is and what it is not
Silhouettes of seven people standing together on the left facing a single person on the right, separated by a vertical cracked line with a darker background on one side and lighter on the other.

Was Paul an Imposter Apostle or Appointed by Jesus?

/
Handling several objections to Paul’s appointment as the 12th Apostle